MAC is up 96% and Natasha Denona is up 59% on Phia, and eye pencils sit near the top of the best-seller list. Here are the eye makeup trends of 2026 and the liquid shadows, liners and palettes to try.

Eye Makeup Trends 2026: Liquid Shadow, Pencils and Palettes Phia Shoppers Love
Eye makeup trends 2026
Eye makeup is where you can see both ends of the market at once. MAC Cosmetics is the fastest-rising mass brand on Phia, up 96% in searches, and Natasha Denona is up 59% as a luxury name. Thrive Causemetics' Brilliant Eye Brightener is the number one best-seller by units, and its Infinity Waterproof pencil is number three. Ogee's Lid Sculpt Liquid Eyeshadow is number four, at $27.
If I read that list quickly, I see a trend toward products that are easy to apply, last through the day, and do not require a palette. Here is what that looks like on the shelf.

Liquid and cream shadow
Liquid and cream shadow is the easy win. MAC's Dazzleshadow and Multisculpt are the two to start with, Urban Decay's Glaze-On is the shimmery one, Charlotte Tilbury's Exagger-Eyes is the waterproof stick, and Merit's Solo Shadow and Ilia's Eye Stylus are the quiet, wearable options.
Apply with a fingertip and tap rather than swipe. It sets quickly, so work fast and leave the edges soft.
What I would skip: layering a powder shadow on top unless the product is fully set. It can crease.
Liquid and cream shadow

Dazzleshadow Longwear Liquid Eye Shadow
MAC Cosmetics

Multisculpt Matte Liquid Eyeshadow + All-over Colour
MAC Cosmetics

24/7 Glaze-On Shimmer Liquid Eyeshadow
Urban Decay

Exagger-Eyes Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick
Charlotte Tilbury

Solo Shadow Cream Eyeshadow
Merit

Eye Stylus Shadow Stick
Ilia

Eye Tint Long-Lasting Liquid Eyeshadow
Armani Beauty

Twin Flames Liquid Eyeshadow
Danessa Myricks Beauty
Pencils and liners: the best-sellers
Two pencils made the best-seller top three, which says something. Pat McGrath's Permagel Ultra Glide is a soft gel, Urban Decay's 24/7 Glide-On is the classic waterproof one, Kosas' Soulgazer is a gel liner, and Huda Beauty's Creamy Kohl is the smudgy smoky one.
Thrive Causemetics is the brand behind the number-one and number-three best-sellers, though I could not find it on Sephora, so the pencils here are the closest alternatives.
Draw a line along your upper lash line, and smudge it a little with a cotton swab for a softer look. What I would skip: pressing hard. Waterproof pencils need very little pressure.

Palettes for people who like a plan
Palettes are for the days you want more than one shade. Natasha Denona's I Need a Nude and Tan palettes are the two I would start with, and her story is worth knowing. She is a Croatian-born, German-raised makeup artist who could not find shadows with the texture and colour she wanted, so she made her own with crushed pearls and chroma crystals.
Makeup by Mario's Ethereal Eyes is the cool-toned mood board, and Pat McGrath's Backstage Eyes Luxe Quads are the compact luxury option.
Buy a palette that matches the colours you already wear. What I would skip: a rainbow palette if your clothes live in neutral shades.
Palettes

I Need a Nude Eyeshadow Palette
Natasha Denona

Tan Eyeshadow Palette
Natasha Denona

Ethereal Eyes™ Eyeshadow Palette: The Original
MAKEUP BY MARIO

Backstage Eyes: Luxe Quads
PAT McGRATH LABS

I Need a Cool Eyeshadow Palette
Natasha Denona

Dazzleshadow 12HR Eyeshadow Stick
MAC Cosmetics

Venus in Fleurs Luxe Eyeshadow Palette: Voyeuristic Vixen
PAT McGRATH LABS

Soulgazer Lengthening Mascara
Kosas
What I would buy first
If I were building an eye kit, I would start with one liquid shadow, one pencil, and one small palette for the days I want more.
The list of best-sellers shows that people want eye products that are easy to apply and last, and that is a good place to start.










