Fall shoes come down to five shapes, including the soft loafer, the tall boot and Mary Janes. I picked the pairs in each that I would happily wear.

Fall Shoes for Women: Loafers, Tall Boots and Mary Janes
The Soft Loafer
Every September I make the same mistake: I panic-buy one pair and wear it into the ground by November. This year I wanted a better plan, so I kept coming back to five shapes: the soft loafer, a tall boot, Mary Janes, brown suede and one red shoe. The loafer is still my anchor. I like the looseness of the Mansur Gavriel Ruched Loafer in Oxblood, the woven texture of the St. Agni Bunto Woven Loafer in Chocolate, and the chunkier gathered shape of the Tony Bianco Grand Loafer in Choc Vintage Leather. The Le Monde Béryl Orlando Moccasin in Taupe Suede is the softer, quieter option.
St. Agni began in Byron Bay in 2014 with founders Lara and Matt Fells and three bags, and its woven leather is still what people know it for. Tony Bianco goes back to 1972, when Tony Bianco opened a small shoe factory in Hawthorn, Melbourne, with his wife Michela and five employees; his sons Anthony and Adam run it now. Those stories make the boards feel like a conversation between ease and polish, not a shopping list. My practical test is to try a loafer with the socks I actually wear and walk around long enough to notice if the heel slips. What I would skip: a soft sole for a day that means hours on hard pavement. A loafer should feel relaxed, not flimsy.



Ruched Loafer in Oxblood
Mansur Gavriel

Bunto Woven Loafer in Chocolate
St. Agni

Orlando Moccasin in Taupe Suede
Le Monde Béryl

Rachel Woven Leather Loafer in Espresso
Loeffler Randall

Minimal Flat Loafer in Black
St. Agni

Miles Loafer in Vintage Brown
Khaite

Gio Loafer in Espresso
Dear Frances

Grand Loafer in Choc Vintage Leather
Tony Bianco

Leo Penny Loafer in Tobacco
Nisolo

Arthur Apron Loafer
aeyde

Gloria Loafer in Choc Vintage Leather
Tony Bianco

Margaux Loafer in Olive Croc Suede
Larroudé
The Tall Boot
A tall boot is the easiest way to make a skirt feel like fall. I like them close to the calf with a low or kitten heel, and in brown before black. Slouchy works too, as long as it looks like you meant it. Tony Bianco's Jordyn has a riding-boot line on a short block heel, and the Rinetta does the same height in espresso suede with a square toe.



Allegra Riding Boot in Plum
Le Monde Béryl

Jordyn Calf Boot in Choc Vintage Leather
Tony Bianco

Carine Boot in Brown Leather
Larroudé

Alexandra 50 Boot
Sarah Flint

Toronto Knee-High Boot in Whiskey Wax
Tony Bianco

Wally Slouch Boot in Espresso
Staud

Marley Croc-Embossed Tall Boot
Loeffler Randall

Rinetta Boot in Espresso Suede
Tony Bianco

Clive Boot in Dark Brown
Khaite

Sajan Leather Boot in Black
Alohas

Fantasy Knee-High Boot in Chocolate Nappa
Tony Bianco

Loch Boot in Espresso
Dear Frances
Mary Janes
I resisted the Mary Jane for years because it felt too sweet. Then I tried one in velvet with a straight trouser and changed my mind. Keep the strap thin and the toe soft, and add a print if you want some bite. Tony Bianco's Bobbi in espresso suede and St. Agni's Ballerina Flat, with its two crossover straps, are the ones I would wear most.



Dance Mary Jane in Black
Mansur Gavriel

Ballerina Flat in Black
St. Agni

Perfect Mary Jane Pump 100
Sarah Flint

Ballet Mary Jane in Bordeaux
Le Monde Béryl

Bobbi Mary Jane Flat in Espresso Suede
Tony Bianco

Ginger Mary Jane in Leopard
Loeffler Randall

Ginger Mary Jane in Brown Velvet
Loeffler Randall

Carla Mary Jane Flat
Tony Bianco

Jane Mary Jane
Freda Salvador

Casilda Mary Jane Pump
Souliers Martinez

Bambi Mary Jane Flat in Black Patent
Tony Bianco

Junia Mary Jane Flat in Zebra
Loeffler Randall
Brown Suede
Suede is the texture I miss most all summer. In a warm brown it goes with denim, grey, black and every camel coat I own. This is where I would put the boot, the moccasin and the flat I plan to wear until it snows. St. Agni's coffee suede loafer, ballet boot and cylinder-heel pump could cover the whole week on their own.



Noelle Suede Ballet Flat in Cacao
Loeffler Randall

Suede Minimal Flat Loafer in Coffee
St. Agni

Jane Flat in Sable Suede
Khaite

Vico Mule in Caramel Suede
Dear Frances

Suede Ballet Boot in Coffee
St. Agni

Camille Boot in Pepper Suede
Le Monde Béryl

Dona Stretch Boot 50 in Dark Brown Suede
Nodaleto

Suede Cylinder Pump in Coffee
St. Agni

Moka Laced Suede Flat
Souliers Martinez

Hydra Shearling Moccasin in Burnt Umber
Larroudé

Gemma Ankle Boot in Espresso Suede
Tony Bianco

Hana Knee-High Suede Boot
aeyde
The Red Shoe
One red shoe changes the whole outfit. I mostly mean oxblood and bordeaux, the color of a good glass of wine, with one brighter pair for the brave. Wear it with navy, grey or all black and let it do the work. Tony Bianco's Cherry, a low-heel court in vino croco, is the easy one to start with.



Topo Bootie in Bordeaux
Dear Frances

Babouche Kitten Heel in Oxblood
Le Monde Béryl

Ines Pump in Burgundy
Larroudé

Palms Boot in Oxblood Suede
Brother Vellies

Veneto Pump in Burgundy Satin
Emme Parsons

Mina Patent Ballerina in Burgundy
Souliers Martinez

Agnes Western Boot in Red
Loeffler Randall

Rosalind Ballet Flat in Burgundy
Alohas

Leather Pointed-Toe Court Shoes
Max Mara

T-Strap Sandals
Toteme

Snake-Printed Leather Mules
Dries Van Noten

Cherry Pump in Vino Croco
Tony Bianco

Pony Hair Loafers
Dries Van Noten

Elliot Sandals
A Emery

Suede Boat Shoes
Miu Miu

Ella Sandals
Aeyde

Viv Rangers Leather Boat Shoes
Roger Vivier

Novus Leather Boat Shoes
The Row

Platform Leather Boat Shoes
Prada

Plaster Caster Leather Driving Shoes
Valentino Garavani

Leather and Suede Boat Shoes
Miu Miu

Pony-Effect Leather Mules
Tod's

Bunnie Bandana Leather Slingback Pumps
Bottega Veneta

Infradito Metallic Leather Sandals
ALAÏA

Bella Python-Embossed Leather Ankle Boots
Khaite

Astrilarge 100mm Two-Tone Leather Ankle Boots
Christian Louboutin

Franciane Leather Platform Sandals
Saint Laurent

Boudoir Bow Leather Mules
Givenchy

Beaded Metallic-Leather Sandals
Gianvito Rossi

Vittoria Thong Leather Slippers
Amina Muaddi

Contrast-Trimmed Leather Mules
Dries Van Noten

Crystal-Embellished Leather Sandals
Chloé

Duchesse Leather Pumps
Balenciaga

Ziva Leather Platform Slingback Sandals
Jimmy Choo

The H Leather Espadrilles
Jacquemus

Sage Leather Sandals
Gabriela Hearst

Giro Leather Heels
Christopher Esber

Ruffled Suede Boat Shoes
JW Anderson

Mid-Heel Leather Ankle Boots
Toteme

Office Leather Mules
Magda Butrym
Where I'd Start
If I had to start from zero, I would buy the loafer and the tall boot first, then let the red shoe be the treat. If you want to keep browsing, I also put together Valentino Shoes for Women and D&G Shoes, Compared.
To round out the look, see GIA BORGHINI Shoes and Jimmy Choo Shoes and Bags.






