Trench Noir

Trench Noir

Black trench coats in leather, cotton and belted wool

A black trench coat guide: leather trench coats, classic cotton trenches and cropped trench jackets, with the details I check before buying one.

The black trench coat, and why it looks sharper than beige

The trench was built for British officers in the First World War. The shoulder straps and the D-rings on the belt were added for the trenches, which is where the name comes from. Burberry patented its gabardine in 1879 and Aquascutum dates its own claim to the 1850s, so the camel version has had more than a century to become the default.

 

I think black is the better buy for fall. It hides a rainy commute, it goes over a hoodie or a slip dress, and it reads a little more severe in the best way. The Pinterest boards I keep saving this month are almost all black trench coats worn long, belted loose and paired with loafers or sneakers.

 

Below are three ways to wear one: a leather trench coat, a black cotton trench in the classic shape, and a cropped trench jacket. I would rather own one good coat for years than three that pill, so each section ends with what I would skip.

Collage of women wearing black trench coats on city streets

The black leather trench coat

A leather trench coat is the one that gets compliments. The Michael Kors Long Faux Leather Trench Coat and the Noize Abby Faux Leather Trench Coat are the easy entry points, with a classic collar and a full belt. If you want more shape, the Avec Les Filles Oversize Raglan Faux Leather Trench Coat drops at the shoulder, and the Avec Les Filles Funnel Neck Slouchy Leather Trench Coat skips the lapel completely, which looks very modern over a black turtleneck.

 

For real leather, the Kimi & Kai Ada Leather Trench Coat and the FURNIQ UK Greenwich Leather Trench Coat are both long and structured. The Manière De Voir Ayleen Leather Biker Trench Coat borrows zips from a moto jacket, and the Bernardo Croc Embossed Faux Leather Trench Coat adds texture without any color.

 

My fitting-room test: raise both arms. If the leather pulls across the back, size up, because it will not relax the way wool does. What I would skip: very shiny faux leather, which reads like vinyl in daylight.

Black cotton trench coats in the classic shape

This is the version you can wear five days a week. The COS Mock-neck cotton trench coat swaps the lapel for a high collar, and the Everlane Modern Trench Coat in black keeps the storm flap and belt but trims the bulk. The Mango Long double-breasted trench coat is the most traditional of the group, long and belted.

 

For a dressier coat, the Reformation x Alexa Chung Cassie Trench Coat and the Hobbs London Skylar Trench Coat are cut close through the waist. The Lauren Ralph Lauren Double Breasted Belted Trench Coat and the Via Spiga Stretch Gabardine Trench Coat both use gabardine, the same tightly woven fabric Burberry made famous. The Banana Republic Archive Reissue Double-Faced Cape-Back Trench Coat has a cape panel at the back that makes it feel special.

 

What I check: the fabric tag. Tightly woven cotton gabardine sheds light rain; thin poly blends wrinkle fast and do not. What I would skip: oversized shoulders if you are petite, since they swallow the frame.

Cropped trench coats and short trench jackets

A cropped trench is the answer if long coats overwhelm you or you mostly wear wide-leg jeans. The Favorite Daughter Charles Crop Trench Coat and Joe's Liz Cropped Trench Coat both stop at the hip and keep the belt, so they still read as a trench. The Naked Wardrobe Faux Leather Crop Trench Coat and the Open Edit Cropped Leather Trench Jacket are shorter and boxier.

 

The Grey Lab Faux Leather Trench Jacket and the Michael Kors Faux Leather Trench Coat sit mid-thigh, a good middle ground. The LBLC the label Winona Leather Trench and the FURNIQ UK Sloane Leather Trench Coat are softer leather that drapes instead of standing away from the body.

 

Style note: a short trench looks best with high-rise pants, so the belt hits your natural waist. What I would skip: a cropped trench worn over a long dress, which cuts you in half.

How I would pick a black trench coat

Start with how you get around. If you walk or take the train, a black cotton trench in gabardine is the hardest working coat in this guide. If you drive and want a coat that does the styling for you, go leather. If you are petite or live in wide-leg pants, the cropped trench is the most flattering shape.

 

Whichever way you go, check three things before you buy: the shoulder seam should sit at your shoulder, the sleeve should cover your wrist bone with your arms forward, and the belt should tie without bunching. A black trench that fits like that will outlast every trend on this page.