What to wear in Iceland comes down to a waterproof shell, merino layers, a Fair Isle sweater and dry boots. I would pack for four seasons in one day and let the lopapeysa set the look.

What to Wear in Iceland: The Wool Sweater Is Newer Than You Think
What to wear in Iceland comes down to a waterproof shell, merino layers, a Fair Isle sweater and dry boots
What the weather decides for you
The lopapeysa feels like it has been around forever, and it has not. Visit Iceland dates the history of the round-yoke wool sweater to the 1950s, with independence in 1944 helping to make it a national symbol that Icelanders of all ages still wear. The yoke pattern itself came from a Norwegian design of the 1930s, influenced by Greenlandic Inuit clothing. Even the local look is borrowed, and it works because it was built for the weather.
That weather is the whole answer to what to wear in Iceland. The official advice is blunt: it changes quickly and the seasons blend into one another, because mild Atlantic air keeps meeting Arctic air. Storms, wind and sudden shifts are normal. I would plan the trip as three layers: a waterproof shell on the outside, wool underneath, and boots that stay dry. Cotton and jeans are the pieces to leave at home, since wind and sideways rain leave you cold and wet.
So the shell comes first. The Torrentshell 3L in berry fig is a three-layer waterproof and windproof jacket that packs into its own pocket, which suits a day bag. The Alta Vista in opal frost is the lighter, hiking-minded option. If you want something that covers more of you, the AmazeTrench in ancient fossil is a long belted trench, and the Weekend Adventure II in beach has a cinched waist and a longer line. The Beta SL in black is GORE-TEX with pit zips, for hikes where you run warm.
My tip: put the hood on in the fitting room, then lift your arms and turn your head. The brim should keep moving with you, not block your side view. And buy the shell a size up from usual so a sweater fits under it.

Waterproof shell jackets
Parkas for the cold side
Iceland does have a cold side, and the one you pack depends on the month. The weather page says storms with extreme winds and rain or snowfall are frequent, so a shell alone will not carry you through a winter evening. That is where an insulated parka earns its space in the suitcase.
The Stormhenge 850 hybrid parka in black is a longline coat with down and recycled fill inside a HydroWall waterproof breathable shell, so it handles both the cold and the wet. The Hikesteller in khaki stone uses waterproof DryVent Mono fabric with an adjustable hood, a softer look for town. The Chelsea down coat in arctic navy has 700-fill-power down and a waterproof coating. The Spyfire in blackout has 800-fill-power goose down with body-mapped baffles, which keeps the warmth where it is needed without turning you into a marshmallow.
For something with a little drama, I would look at the Icelandite II in dark green: waterproof, 550 TurboDown fill, a belted waist and faux fur trim. Picture her stepping off a bus in a small fishing town with that hood up and a scarf tucked in. The Silent Down Long Parka in berry brown and the Jackson Glacier in smolder blue are long quilted options, and the Moss in navy is an insulated long coat.
Test the hood and the hem. Pull the hood up and check you can still turn your head, then sit down and make sure the coat covers the back of your thighs. What I would skip: a down coat with no waterproof finish if you plan to stand near a waterfall, since wet down stops doing its job.


Stormhenge 850 Down Hybrid Parka
REI Co-op

Hikesteller Parka
The North Face

Chelsea Down Coat
Marmot

Spyfire Down Parka
KUHL

Silent Down Long Parka
Patagonia

Moss Insulated PU Coat
Helly Hansen

Icelandite II Waterproof 550 TurboDown Parka
Columbia

Jackson Glacier Parka
Patagonia
Base layers that handle spray
Seljalandsfoss gives you the best argument for base layers. Spray from the plunge pool can reach the path behind the falls, and the guide says to dress in waterproofs and be ready to get wet. If your first layer is damp cotton, the day is over by lunch. A merino or synthetic layer is what keeps it going.
Merino is the one I would pick for most women. The Classic Thermal crew from Smartwool in coral reef is a simple merino top, and the quarter zip in black Fair Isle Fun has Nordic print sleeves, a nod to the lopapeysa that nobody will see under a jacket but you. The Icebreaker 260 Tech crewe in midnight navy is soft 100% merino jersey, and the Oasis Vertex half zip in black snow has an alpine geometric print. The Merino 250 crew in horizon purple is a heavyweight 100% merino piece.
If you run warm on hikes, the Patagonia Capilene Midweight crew in ink black has a smooth face that slides easily under other layers. The Kari Traa Nova half zip in dark steel and the Swix Polaris half zip with its cream and tan chevron yoke are good for cold mornings, because the zip lets you vent as you climb.
Do a quick test: rub the fabric against the inside of your wrist. It should feel smooth, not scratchy, since you will wear it all day. What I would skip: anything labeled cotton blend for a hiking day, because wool takes a long time to dry off, and cotton takes longer.


Classic Thermal Merino Crew Base Layer Top
Smartwool

Classic Thermal Merino Base Layer 1/4 Zip
Smartwool

260 Tech Long-Sleeve Crewe Base Layer Top
Icebreaker

Merino 260 Oasis Vertex Alpine Geo 1/2-Zip Top
Icebreaker

Merino 250 Long-Sleeve Crew Base Layer Top
REI Co-op

Capilene Midweight Crew Base Layer Top
Patagonia

Nova 1/2-Zip Baselayer Top
Kari Traa

Polaris Baselayer 1/2-Zip Top
Swix
Fair Isle sweaters, the local look
Icelandic wool has two layers, long water-resistant tog on the outside and soft warm thel on the inside. It is the reason the sweater from the farm became the sweater from the shop window. You do not need to buy a hand-knit lopapeysa to get the idea, since a round yoke in at least two colors is the basic design feature.
The Fair Isle yoke is the closest match. The Darwen turtleneck from Barbour in burgundy has a cream yoke, and the Port Kinnis from Seasalt Cornwall in gray is a merino blend with a blue yoke. The Donegal crewneck from Marine Layer in cream multi has burgundy and navy in the pattern, and the Alpine Yoke from Celtic & Co. in oatmeal multi has a multicolor band across the shoulders. The Whistles jumper in gray is a wool blend in a quieter palette.
For a darker look, the Nordic sweater from Williams Athletic Club in black is a funnel neck with a cream yoke, and the Edgewood Heritage crew from Smartwool in black is a lightweight relaxed knit. The British Highlands cardigan in green is the one I would wear in a guesthouse, over a thermal, with the sleeves pushed up for breakfast.
Pull the neckline over your chin to check it does not itch, then look at the yoke from the inside for loose floats that could catch. What I would skip: a sweater you must dry-clean, because a few days of travel turn into airing and rolling it up.


Edgewood Heritage Crew Sweater
Smartwool

Nordic Wool Blend Sweater
Williams Athletic Club

Alpine Yoke Fair Isle Sweater
Celtic & Co.

Darwen Fair Isle Turtleneck Sweater
Barbour

Port Kinnis Fair Isle Merino Wool Blend Sweater
Seasalt Cornwall

Donegal Fair Isle Crewneck Sweater
Marine Layer

Wool Blend Fairisle Knit Jumper
Whistles

British Highlands Crew Neck Cardigan
Celtic & Co.
Boots that stay dry
Boots decide whether you enjoy the day, and the trail is often wet before the weather even turns. Look for waterproof lining, a lugged sole and a mid cut that covers the ankle.
The HOKA Kaha 3 GTX in granola and bark is a GORE-TEX hiker with a lugged sole, and the Lowa Renegade Evo GTX Mid in graphite and apricot has apricot laces on a gray leather boot. The Merrell Moab 3 Mid in granite is a suede and mesh waterproof boot, and the KEEN Targhee IV Mid in brindle has nubuck leather uppers with a durable TPU outsole. The Oboz Sawtooth X Mid in eagle and the On Cloudrock Mid in sphinx and sand are mid waterproof hikers with a lighter look.
For the colder trips, the two Sorel boots are the ones I would look at: the Caribou WP in black with a faux fur collar and rubber shell, and the Joan of Arctic in black with faux fur trim. Both are waterproof winter boots made for snow and slush, not for long hikes.
Try them on in the afternoon with the socks you will wear, and kick the toe against a wall. Your heel should stay down when you walk uphill. What I would skip: breaking in a new pair on the plane. Wear them for a week at home first, and leave the woolly hats and gloves in the car if the spray is heavy, since wool dries slowly.

Kaha 3 GTX Hiking Boots
HOKA

Moab 3 Mid Waterproof Hiking Boots
Merrell

Targhee IV Mid Waterproof Hiking Boots
KEEN

Renegade Evo GTX Mid Hiking Boots
Lowa

Sawtooth X Mid Waterproof Hiking Boots
Oboz

Cloudrock Mid Waterproof Hiking Boots
On

Caribou WP Waterproof Boot
SOREL

Joan of Arctic Waterproof Boot
SOREL
Pack for four seasons, wear wool
I would start with the shell and the boots, since they carry the trip. Then add one merino base layer and one Fair Isle sweater, and the parka only if you are going in the colder months.
Pack for four seasons, even if the forecast looks calm. Icelanders have been dressing for this since Hans Kristjansson began making protective clothing for fishermen in Sudureyri in 1926, and the lopapeysa is just the friendly end of that story. Wear wool, keep the cotton and the jeans at home, and let the weather do what it likes. You will be warm, dry and a little smug about it.














