What to Wear With Leggings: Sixty Years of Long Tops and Flat Shoes

What to Wear With Leggings: Sixty Years of Long Tops and Flat Shoes

A styling guide to what to wear with leggings this October: oversized knits, longline shirts, jackets, flats, sneakers and booties.

A styling guide to what to wear with leggings this October: oversized knits, longline shirts, jackets, flats, sneakers and booties, with why each pairing works. I would keep the top long and the shoe simple.

A short history of leggings, then the pairs

In the 1960s, Emilio Pucci and Mary Quant picked up a newly stretchy fabric and made slim, stirruped leggings to wear with mod minis and tunic dresses. For the first time legwear was there for style, not warmth. Two decades later aerobics and Jane Fonda videos pushed them out into the street, usually under an oversized sweatshirt. That is still the formula, and it is why what to wear with leggings has a short answer: something long and loose on top.

 

The debate over whether leggings are pants or just an accessory under other clothes has never really ended. I land in the middle. Black leggings are a base layer you decide how much of to show, so the pair matters more than the top. Lululemon, founded by Chip Wilson in Vancouver in 1998, built its name on Luon, a nylon-lycra blend that was thicker and more pant-like than the thin exercise tights before it. That thickness is the thing to look for.

 

Start with the black pairs that hold their shape. The Commando faux leather control top and the Lysse faux leather with vertical seaming read like trousers, so they take a blazer without any fuss. The Eileen Fisher ankle pair has a clean hem that grazes the ankle, which is the length I would wear with flats. The SPANX Booty Boost and the Zella Live In both have a wide, high waistband that stays put, and the Commando Butter pair has raw-cut hems that do not curl.

 

Do the squat test before you commit: face a mirror in bright light, squat, and look for sheerness at the seat and thigh. A good black pair should stay solid.

Collage of leggings outfits with oversized sweaters

Oversized sweaters and cardigans, long enough to cover

Proportion does the work here. A fitted leg gets a big top, and the top should reach at least to the top of the thigh so the waistband never has to carry the outfit. In my fashion dreams, she is walking to a Sunday market in October in a chunky knit that nearly meets her knees.

 

The MANGO oversized wool sweater in dark heather gray is the plain version, a classic crewneck with an oversized cut. The AllSaints Asha is the dramatic one: a black mock neck in a wool-enriched knit, cut very wide. The Kenneth Cole cable knit in heather gray is chunkier, and the H&M alpaca-blend jumper in brown has ribbing at the cuffs and hem that gives the big shape a clean edge. Nylon relies on elastane for its stretch, so a bulky knit is a good match: the leggings stay smooth and the sweater supplies the volume.

 

For cardigans, length is the point. The Eileen Fisher long wool cardigan and the Karen Kane open-front one both fall past the hip. The Splendid Desiree has a shawl collar and a removable belt, which gives you a waist when you want one. The Free People Opal cable cardigan in pale tea is the slouchy, drop-shoulder option.

 

Test: stand with your arms down and check where the hem ends. If it stops at the widest part of the hip, go longer or add a belt.

 

What I would skip: a cropped, snug sweater. It leaves the waistband showing and fights the shape of the legs.

Collage of 20 pieces for what to wear with leggings

Oversized button-ups and crew sweatshirts

The 1980s answer was a sweatshirt with leg warmers. The updated one is a longline shirt or a boxy crew, worn with a sleek black pair and flat shoes. The shirttail is the hem to watch: it should cover the seat, because that is where most people want a little extra coverage.

 

For shirts, the Eileen Fisher longline button-up in a coffee-brown check has the most length. The Alex Mill Jo stripe in jade green is oversized cotton with a long shirttail, and the H&M oversized shirt in white has a rounded hem and a pleated back yoke. The Vince in optic white is crisp cotton poplin. I would leave the top two buttons undone and push the sleeves to the elbow, so the white against black reads as sharp, not stiff.

 

For sweatshirts, the KADA cupro crew in cherry is longline with invisible shoulder seams, a more polished shape than a typical hoodie. The Free People striped French terry in periwinkle has dropped shoulders, the Nike ImpossiblySoft is boxy in black and smoke gray, and the ANINE BING Miles in washed black leopard is brushed cotton fleece. Any of them works with a slim leg because the shoulder does the dropping.

 

Test: sit down in the shirt. If it rides up past the waistband when you reach forward, it is too short for leggings.

 

What I would skip: a stiff, cropped shirt in a wide cut. The volume ends right where the leggings begin.

Collage of everyday leggings looks with jackets and sneakers

Quilted, leather and tailored jackets

The Barbour Annandale is the slightly fitted quilted jacket with a corduroy collar. Quilting gives a sleek leg a country feeling, and I would wear it in October with ankle boots.

 

That corduroy collar shows up again on the Save The Duck Jodie in gunmetal gray, a lighter quilted jacket with contrast corduroy on the collar and pocket flaps. For a harder edge, go to leather. The Frye bomber is soft lambskin with ribbed trim, so it stops at the hip and leaves the long line of the leg alone. The MANGO Sabina and the superdown Blakely in worn-in brown are cropped faux leather, and the Free People Fourline moto is lined in plush faux shearling for the cold days. The Sanctuary Alana is the oversized one, with dropped shoulders and a collar you can pop.

 

Hem length is the whole story with jackets. Cropped styles should end at the waist or just below, with a longer top underneath. The ALL THE WAYS Kourtney blazer is a fitted black single-breasted cut with sharp shoulders, and it is the one I would pick when leggings have to look like trousers.

 

Test: put the jacket on over a sweater, not a tee. If you cannot raise your arms to shoulder height, size up.

 

What I would skip: a long, thin trench-style piece with a long cardigan under it. Too many long layers flatten each other.

Collage of leggings with boots and long coats

Ballet flats, sneakers and ankle boots

The shoe sets the length of the leg. Ankle-grazing leggings with a low shoe make a clean line, and this is where the 1960s mod idea returns, with the foot kept simple.

 

Ballet flats are the easiest. The Dolce Vita Ritla has a dainty bow at the rounded toe, and the Tory Burch Reva is a foldable leather flat with a logo medallion, handy for travel. The Coach Margot has a cushioned footbed and a flexible rubber sole, with a polished buckle at the toe. Wear them with a long sweater and the outfit looks put together without trying.

 

For sneakers, the Veja Campo is white leather with natural suede and a cream sole, and the soles are made from wild Amazonian rubber. The Vince Oasis in milk and nightblue is a retro low-top with a contrast logo, and the Dolce Vita Merit adds gold trim to a white leather lace-up. White sneakers work best with black leggings because the contrast is crisp.

 

For boots, the Blondo Proper is a black suede bootie with a waterproof finish, a lug sole and an inside zip, which is the one for wet October days. The Franco Sarto Luella has a square toe and a low block heel. Tuck the legging hem inside a bootie so no fabric bunches.

 

Test: with ballet flats, check that the heel does not slip when you walk, since leggings give no extra grip.

 

What I would skip: a chunky platform boot with a very oversized sweater. It makes the whole outfit heavy.

The way I would put it together

I would begin with one black pair that passes the squat test. Pick the length first: ankle with flats, full length with boots. Then add something long on top, a cardigan or a longline shirt that covers the seat.

 

After that, finish with one jacket, either a quilted one for a weekend or a leather one for a night out, and choose the shoe last. Keep to a single volume: if the top is oversized, the shoe stays neat.

 

Pucci and Quant had it figured out sixty years ago. Slim on the leg, easy everywhere else, and a little attitude at the hem.